Fantasy Politics

by Thomas R. Wells

Fantasy politics starts from the expectation that wishes should come true, that the best outcome imaginable is not just possible but overwhelmingly likely. Brexit is classic fantasy politics, premised on the delightful optimism that if the UK were only freed of its shackles it would easily be able to negotiate the best deals imaginable.

The great appeal of fantasy politics is that you it puts you in complete control. Using the power of your imagination, you get to control not only what you will do but also how everyone else will react. Sometimes you also control laws of nature, such as economics or even physics. Unsurprisingly, this kind of politics tends to go your way. Decisiveness is the only quality needed for your actions to succeed. Everyone recognises your awesomeness and competes to serve your interests, whether motivated by admiration or fear.

Why is fantasy politics so popular these days? One reason is that it is so much easier than real politics. In real politics we try to address multiple, intersecting, complicated collective action problems – like the high cost of housing or sexism in the labour market – while at the same time grappling with the deep diversity of beliefs, values, and interests within and between societies. Real politics is a difficult and time-consuming activity that usually requires dissatisfactory compromise with reality and what other people want. It is much easier to make-believe our way to our favoured outcomes, i.e. as Boris Johnson put it after the 2016 Brexit referendum, “Our policy is having our cake and eating it.”

Fantasy politics is also much more inherently satisfying than real politics. Fantasy politics gives us the opportunity to express our political values and loyalties and this is something that feels good in itself. This contrasts with the meagre psychic rewards of participating in real politics, as merely one voice among millions of equals no more special than anyone else. Moreover, we don’t have to set our hopes on the eventual, possible achievement of some policy we want. We can enjoy the psychic benefits of our political fantasies here and now.

This psychological turn is part of the decades long transformation of politics from a serious practical business into a mere entertainment that serves as a diversion from the challenges and worries of our real lives. Those who are passionate about politics thereby resemble the sports fans coming together to escape their everyday concerns. Political fantasists also resemble sports fans in their willingness to set aside the respect for expertise that they expect to receive in their day jobs as accountants or plumbers or coal miners or whatever. Caring a lot about how well your team does is not the same thing as being interested in how the game is actually played at that level. Nevertheless, just as football fans enjoy the right to offer strategic advice to players and team-managers (and to insult their choices and judgement), so politics fans enjoy pretending that they know best how politics should be played.

The psychic benefits of fantasy politics seem especially attractive to those who feel neglected and unheard by the political system, such as the white working class in towns left behind by the modern economy. (The Brexit referendum was decided by 2.8 million ‘non-voters’ who had lost faith and interest in real politics – unsurprisingly they are even more bitter about it now.) For these losers, fantasy politics offers their only way to feel politically significant.  Moreover, like the victim’s dreams of revenge against their bully, these resentment driven fantasies are not kind.

It should also be mentioned that fantasy politics is everywhere these days because fantasy itself is so popular. The kookiness of America’s gun rights movement, for example, has a lot to do with its animating hero fantasy of the regular guy standing up against the bad guys or evil government. In these movie screenplays that they write themselves, the good guy never misses and the bad guys never manage to shoot straight.

Finally, demand creates its own supply. Political entrepreneurs like Trump or Farage or Boris come out of the woodwork and start pitching fantasy products for voters to buy. Of course there is no alternative to real politics in the long run – if we want to get things done. But so long as large numbers of our fellow citizens are disinterested in outcomes and prefer wallowing in fantasy, populist politicians will make hay.

Like what you're reading? Don't keep it to yourself!
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on Reddit
Reddit
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin
Email this to someone
email