Comments

Ingolf

So we can each only vote for one essay? Wouldn't two (or better still three) help to arrive at a more calibrated result?

South Asian

With 46 entries, the need for voting to reduce the number to something that can be handled by four judges disappears. It would take one extra round of winnowing to reduce the pool to the twenty they are going to look at any ways.

My recommendation would be to let the voting remain but for the judges to look at all 46 entries. This would yield useful information on how well voting works as a determinant of quality. Or, it can yield a sense of the extent to which the popular perception of quality differs from that of the judges.

Jim H.

Several people in my family want to vote, but we only have one computer. If we all vote, will that disqualify each of our votes?

Duncan

Just a typo note: 28 should read News from the Zona, not New from the Zona. Ditto for the voting form.

Abbas Raza

Ingolf, yeah I've read Kenneth Arrow too. :-) For now we'll stick with just one vote per person.

South Asian, we have an unusually low number of nominees for this prize, and would like to keep the rules uniform for all the prizes.

Jim, go ahead and have everyone vote. I'll sort it out.

Duncan, thanks, I've fixed it.

Bruce A. Dixon

We only got around to putting something on our site this morning --- 8 AM Eastern Time, US, asking folks to visit this site and vote for either of our two entries. Should we leave it up tomorrow and change the date, or what?

Abbas Raza

Bruce, don't worry, you've sqeaked into the semi-finalists. The voting round is now over.

Acai Berry Optimum

Excellent list for nominees... Keep up the good job!

Top Grade Acai

To be honest, I don't think The Black Agenda: Liar Liar! should be listed as a nominee. I find that title alone is a bit racist, and I doubt I'm the only one. All the other nominees are good though, especially 3quarksdaily!

Antoine

Hi there! I am here for the first time and like what and how you write. Hope to hear from you soon and something new ) My rapidshare SE( http://www.rapidsharemix.com ) for your use

PavelRybakov30

недорогой ремонт квартир в Киеве

Supra Vaider

*Cool piercing!*_*

Jonathan

My nominee (http://canopycanopycanopy.com/10/she_goes_covered) somehow got lost or was cut.

Taobao

That's not his. Steve's is black*_*

Buy from taobao

Um...like the style of your writing.*_*

oakley sunglasses

++**When poured, the wine is milky and brickish red. Floral and very feminine, it offers a nose of blackberries, lavender, and cassis, with lightly herbal overtones of basil and fresh strawberries. //--

credit loans

I took my first mortgage loans when I was not very old and that supported my family very much. Nevertheless, I require the auto loan also.

Herve leger

Thank You for posting this. i really enjoyed reading this!!

Australia UGG

My parents have medicare. Almost all big hospitals around here accept medicare. So they can get good medical services. It’s impossible that no doctor or hospital accept medicare. If that happens, it’s time for the government to make big changes in medical systems.

home loans

I guess that to receive the personal loans from banks you should present a great reason. Nevertheless, one time I have got a college loan, because I wanted to buy a house.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment