November 05, 2012
America is Always Far Away
by Mara Jebsen
The idea of civilization, bit by bit, helps holds together opposites, whose only former identity existed in the opposition to the Other.--Edouard Glissant
No one has ever measured, not even poets, how much the heart can hold.--Zelda Fitzgerald
America is always far away, particularly in November. In November in New York, the mind bends toward California, or any way of imagining how chaotically big the country is. Is it possible to fathom that all of these people really belong together? This November, we are asked to consider the narratives and ideas that yoke us so uncomfortably. But we all seem to know different narratives and to consider them differently. For this reason, we should reflect on the rather remarkable combination of faith, apathy and sophistication that prevents us from resorting to bloodshed if we find ourselves governed by a party we dislike.
For some reason, in November, I become transfixed by the image of a transcontinental train. I think of the train tracks spanning from New Orleans to Los Angeles, carrying lots of hopeful and deperate families during the second wave of the Great Migration. I try to imagine this moment for this population: the first unsegregated streets, these first palms, the first blue glimpse of the Pacific. It is a moment in our history I do not know enough about.
Personally, I feel most patriotic when I am listening to Bob Dylan or Ray Charles. So much of American music seems to contain, and melodically resolve, our violent narratives within it. It makes one vainly wish that music could be a model; could be the idea that holds opposites together. All citizens, even musicians and poets, are occasionally called upon to test how much the heart can hold. Some artists can even make a career of it. I think of Whitman, containing, stretching, containing. I want to tell him: I, too, contain multitudes, but they don't always get along.
To expand the container, to even name the sensation of holding in your consciousness the idea of multitudes, the geographic vastness of this place, the strangeness of belonging to it, is very difficult. One November I mashed-up "Dying Swan" by the Duke Quartet, a snippet of Dylan lyrics, and a poem first published at fogged clarity as "Mirages," but now renamed "America is Always Far Away." I offer it in this container because I think it sounds a little like what it feels like to be here, now, nervous and determined, imagining America.
Posted by Mara Jebsen at 12:05 AM | Permalink






















Comments
For those of us who prefer neither ruling party, November is not about dreams of victory and broken promises, but is rather the precipice of a long-rising wave of chatter and delusion that prepares to crash, as it always does on Election Day, only to slowly rise again.
Thank you for the music and for reminding us that our nation's many narratives are born by poets and singers and migrants, not hollow wailing politicians.
Posted by: Akim Reinhardt | Nov 5, 2012 11:29:23 AM
Akim, I think the excitement and anxiety everyone feels around the political promises (and lies) are actually based on our hope that the music, the poetry and the faraway dream will continue to define the idea of America and better still, some day the whole world. No one votes for the chatter. We keep doing the same thing hoping for a different result. That is one definition of insanity. In a strange way, this somewhat futile exercise actually helps us to remain sane and not sink into unalloyed cynicism - the hope that things might indeed get better.
Posted by: Ruchira | Nov 5, 2012 11:45:10 AM
I think you are both helping to clarify what I wanted to say here. We attach so much emotion to the landscapes we are told belong to us, and to the idea that allows us to think we have some stake/power in the way the country is, and will continue to be. I agree that the aesthetic--the music, the poetry, the beauty of the ideal america--are part of what binds us into this practically abusive relationship with a corrupt system. And yet, as Ruchira points out, it seems emotionally impossible to cut all ties/hope in the possibility of the project and retain your sanity. For many, anyway.
Posted by: Mara | Nov 5, 2012 11:55:58 AM
This is beautiful Mara.
Posted by: Maniza | Nov 5, 2012 4:41:17 PM
Post a comment