July 27, 2012
The United States is the deadliest wealthy country in the world. Can science help us explain, or even solve, our national crisis?
Eric Michael Johnson in The Primate Diaries blog at Scientific American:
While everyone agrees the blame should ultimately be placed on the perpetrator of this violence, the fact remains that the United States has one of the highest murder rates in the industrialized world. Of the 34 countries in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), the U.S. ranks fifth in homicides just behind Brazil (highest), Mexico, Russia, and Estonia. Our nation also holds the dubious honor of being responsible for half of the worst mass shootings in the last 30 years. How can we explain why the United States has nearly three times more murders per capita than neighboring Canada and ten times more than Japan? What makes the land of the free such a dangerous place to live?
There have been hundreds of thoughtful explorations of this problem in the last week, though three in particular have encapsulated the major issues. Could it be, as science writer David Dobbs argues at Wired, that “an American culture that fetishizes violence,” such as the Batman franchise itself, has contributed to our fall? “Culture shapes the expression of mental dysfunction,” Dobbs writes, “just as it does other traits.”
Perhaps the push arrived with the collision of other factors, as veteran journalist Bill Moyers maintains, when the dark side of human nature encountered political allies who nurture our destructive impulses? “Violence is our alter ego, wired into our Stone Age brains,” he says. “The NRA is the best friend a killer’s instinct ever had.”
More here.
Posted by S. Abbas Raza at 05:42 AM | Permalink






















Comments
"Can science help us explain, or even solve, our national crisis?"
Sigmund Freud advocated for a division in psychiatry for the psychoanalysis of groups, nations, and even civilization itself.
So, under current conditions we must not only hope it can be done, it must be done.
Posted by: Dredd | Jul 27, 2012 12:20:18 PM
Finally, someone to put all this madness in perspective. When it happened last Friday, I said to myself, This is a CULTURAL problem. And it is. America has spend the last ten years bombing the shit out of a huge swath of the world, and yet we all pretend like that doesn't have an effect. As if treating the rest of the world like one giant bulls-eye doesn't have some kind of psychological blowback. It does, and it did, and it manifested itself in the person of James Holmes. Some people are shrugging off what he did, as if to say, Oh well, it's happened before and it's going to happen again and there's really nothing we can do about it, but I don't think so. I think Holmes is a bellweather. I think America is coming apart at the seams. I think Holmes, inadvertently, of course, hit where it hurt the most, at the epicenter of our collective dreamlife. You can guage the collective psyche of the USA by looking at the fantasies it chooses to indulge in. To try and dismiss the culture we live in seems childish to me. You can't have it both ways. You can't have your culture be the most important and impervious in the world and then turn around and say that it really doesn't matter.
Posted by: CV | Jul 27, 2012 1:56:37 PM
Post a comment