June 04, 2012
WTF in China
by Sarah Firisen
I expected China to be different; exotic, challenging, overwhelming in its otherness. But, in many ways, it was depressingly familiar; the mall next to my apartment building had a Gap, an H&M, a Subway and a Baskin Robbins. The New York Pizza restaurant was always at least as busy as the excellent Dim Sum restaurant a few doors down from it. Beijing and Shanghai each have a 5th Avenue equivalent sporting a Louis Vuitton, an enormous Cartier, an equally huge Tiffanys, gigantic Apple stores and all the brands that you'd expect to accompany these. I saw a few Aston Martin and Porsche dealerships and it seemed like every other person was driving an Audi.
My tour guide at the Great Wall of China, Leo, looked at my iPhone and asked, "4S?" I replied yes and he bemoaned the fact that his was only an iPhone 4. By the way, you can get great 3G phone reception at the Great Wall. The Pudong area in Shanghai, which was all farmland 20 years ago, is now adding fantastical skyscrapers so quickly that, when I left for a week to go to Beijing, I thought buildings would pop up while I was away.
There is restricted access to the Internet in China, but it wasn't as bad as I thought it would be and clearly the barriers are pretty easy to work around. Leo asked if I'd like to be his Facebook friend and told me he'd friend me when he got home and could get on the VPN that went around the country's firewall.
But in ways that I wasn't expecting, China was as foreign and incomprehensible as anywhere I've ever been in my life. In the roughly 5 weeks (on and off) that I was there, I had more truly inexplicable encounters and conversations than in the rest of my life put together. My colleague Diana and I coined a phrase, WTF in China (WTFIC). We'd say this to each other every time there was really nothing else to say because words failed us.
One day in Beijing, we were sitting in a taxi in heavy traffic. We noticed a few vendors going between the cars selling mobile phone car chargers. This seemed like a clever idea. Then Diana noticed that each vendor had chargers in one hand and a live turtle in the other. What was the deal with the turtles? Were they selling them? Were they a marketing gimmick? We emailed Leo, who had offered to help us post-tour with any questions. Before I got his reply back, I said to Diana, "you know, even once he answers us, we're not going to be any more illuminated. I just know it's going to be a WTF in China issue." And indeed, this was Leo's answer, "For turtles, they are the symbol of longevity and fortune, so people may buy when they get bored in traffic!" Clearly, this answer made perfect logical sense to Leo. And to all the people sitting in rush hour traffic jams making a spur of the moment purchase of an animal that would probably outlive them.
And talking of driving in China…sometimes driving down the road, it was very hard to tell the difference between "something major has happened" and just the normal everyday chaos. Every day I felt like I took my life in my hands just getting a taxi to the office. Every taxi driver drives insanely fast and wildly, honking his horn even if there are no other cars on the road. It turns out that most of the Shanghai taxi drivers are living and working there illegally from other provinces and none of them seem to know how to get to almost anywhere in Shanghai. I became conversant in enough Mandarin to communicate and direct them to my office and back to my apartment building because this seemed to be a survival tactic.
When I was able to move beyond my fear for my life on these car rides and ones in Beijing, I noticed that cars often stopped, seemingly in the middle of the road or lined up on the hard shoulder, particularly at the weekend. This never helped the terrible traffic congestion. We asked Leo what that was all about. He told us that driving is a pretty new phenomenon for most people in Shanghai and Beijing and they see it as a social activity. When they go out for the day, they want to drive along with their friends. So they'll park in the meridian or by the side of the road to wait for them to catch up. Given that they all have cell phones, I'm not sure why they can't just track each other via GPS or phone and say, "where are you?" But again, this seemed a perfectly reasonable activity to Leo.
It was an interesting time to be in China: the Bo Xilai scandal was unravelling and the saga of the blind Chinese dissident Chen Guangcheng was unfolding. I only knew this because I read the New York Times every day. From what I saw of the China Daily (an English language Chinese newspaper), these events were not happening as far as the average Chinese citizen was concerned. And yet, I never sensed that most people felt oppressed by the regime, at least not on a daily basis. Reading the China Daily and talking with people, it's clear that there is a general sense, not necessarily unreasonably so, that the US talks a good game on freedom and civil rights, but that we're not always the torch bearers that we like to think we are.
I'm sure that Westerners are as inexplicable and seemingly bizarre to the Chinese as they often seemed to us. One day, I took my colleague's three daughters out shopping. We got a cab back to our apartment building and after I'd paid the fare, the taxidriver kept gesturing at the three girls sitting in the back. At first, I thought that he wanted to charge me more for the extra people in the car (it sometimes feels like everyone is running a scam in China). But, I finally realized that he thought that the three girls were my daughters and he was marvelling that someone might have three children and that those children would all be girls! Those crazy Westerners!
While I was in China, I facilitated some sessions on the use of storytelling as a leadership and business skill for our Chinese colleagues. We also ran some other soft skill sessions: graphics, executive presence and others. The local participants showed a real eagerness to participate in these sessions, far more so than when I've run these in the US or Europe. Shanghai is becoming a modern city of skyscrapers seemingly overnight and this expedited pace is often palpable in much else about the Chinese and their eagerness to be modern; they want to take on western ways and skills, drive Audis and wear their Prada outfits while talking on their iPhones . But they'll do it on their terms, taking our expertise and elements of our lifestyle and synthesizing them into something that works for their uniquely Chinese sensibilities and ways of thinking.
In many ways, the best metaphor for China is the electrical outlets: they will take a plug from almost any other country (maybe all countries, I wasn't in a position to exhaustively test this). Most days, I've had a UK plug in one outlet and a US plug in another and everything charged just fine. China really does aims to be all things to all people. We may not fully understand its ways, but we underestimate it at our peril.
Posted by Sarah Firisen at 12:10 AM | Permalink






















Comments
Nice piece... I liked this line in particular: "And to all the people sitting in rush hour traffic jams making a spur of the moment purchase of an animal that would probably outlive them."
Posted by: Liam | Jun 4, 2012 8:29:22 AM
More parachute journalism. More "exotic orientalism". WTFIC, how about WTFUSA, when you see the police in liberal cities brutalizing the poor. When you see large numbers of people who actually believe in something as bizarre as "American Exceptionalism", where you see people deliberately returning to the Dark Ages. Where Climate Denial rules. I could go on and on, but really, you wouldn't get it. It's too ordinary for you.
Posted by: PatrickInBeijing | Jun 4, 2012 10:04:19 AM
If you are stuck in traffic in Beijing, you can call a person and they will come out to your location on a motorcycle to pick you up and take you to where you need to go. Another person with them will drive your car to that location. It costs $50.
Posted by: Alan | Jun 4, 2012 10:16:29 AM
"I finally realized that he thought that the three girls were my daughters and he was marvelling that someone might have three children and that those children would all be girls! Those crazy Westerners"
This is what I like about the Chinese. They are always interested in your family - sometimes, too interested. But they are never cold or indifferent.
China is a fascinating place to visit, especially if you go beyond Beijing and Shanghai to places like Dunhuang on the silk road or Yunnan. There are some places where a foreigner will still be stared at as an amazingly exotic sight. In some ways it is like the U.S. in the sixties: drivers don't wear seatbelts, everyone smokes and most laws are taken with a large grain of salt. In fact, the U.S. is a nanny state in comparison.
Posted by: Ralston McTodd | Jun 4, 2012 10:27:55 AM
I hope that wasn't journalism... Stupendous assertion of a dual norm where upon failing expectations of the exotic asserted upon the other, the author seems to instant expect the only other option, that being the dominant western one.
"In many ways, the best metaphor for China is the electrical outlets: they will take a plug from almost any other country "
I think the metaphor serves not to explain china, but western cultural hegemony, I don't think one needs to stretch to freud for this one.
*fact correction, chinese plugs are common with Australian plugs, the fact that they are so 'receiving' is again for the hegemon.
Posted by: derin | Jun 4, 2012 10:38:26 AM
Personally, I've had trouble with plugs in China.
Posted by: Ralston McTodd | Jun 4, 2012 10:45:43 AM
Patrick, the author is Western and does say, "I'm sure that Westerners are as inexplicable and seemingly bizarre to the Chinese as they often seemed to us." And it doesn't seem like she was making any value judgments, just sharing her stories from a trip to a place that was foreign.
Derin, fact: she was talking about outlets, not plugs. And the universal outlets she refers to arose out of the need to integrate Hong Kong, with its UK-style, enormous plugs, with the type used by the rest of the country.
Posted by: Michael | Jun 4, 2012 10:57:23 AM
Hey Patrick. . .Settle down brother. There are plenty of articles on 3QD about all of the issues you discussed. This is just a tidbit of harmless travel journalism, not a horrible and scathing critique of China. If you took offense then you are clearly missing the point.
Posted by: DrunktankDan | Jun 4, 2012 1:03:31 PM
I wonder when they'll get tired of bad air.
Posted by: Shelley | Jun 4, 2012 1:20:34 PM
My wife and I both got sick from Beijing air in just a few days.
Posted by: Ralston McTodd | Jun 4, 2012 1:32:32 PM
Electric plugs are a cultural hegemon? I didn't realize that the technology of connecting electrical devices to the electricity source is a cultural matter, but if someone believes that everything is "cultural," then I guess it is, to them.
Posted by: JonJ | Jun 5, 2012 11:21:52 AM
Is this a joke? So you went to China expecting something out of an American Kung fu movie, felt surprised that Chinese people had electricity and iPhones, and then decided once again that they are a bizarre people by naming everything they do "wtf in china"? This has got to be fucking satire, and a rather shallow and terribly written one at that
Posted by: Shane | Jun 5, 2012 2:13:34 PM
The authours comment on taxi drivers is a false one - I have lived here for 8 years, and though much of what is talked about in the article is true... I can assure you all that it was the fault of her Chinese that the drivers couldn't take her places!
Posted by: Rich | Jun 5, 2012 8:37:01 PM
"But, in many ways, it was depressingly familiar; the mall next to my apartment building had a Gap, an H&M, a Subway and a Baskin Robbins."
It's not clear to me why seeing American brands in China should be "depressing." You do recall having seen Hondas and Volkswagens in the US right? Did they leave you feeling blue?
Less snarkily, the view that having cities worldwide be similar reduces diversity is problematic; the fact that you find both Chinese takeout and Subway in Beijing and New York does make those cities more similar, but what this means is that each inhabitant of Beijing and NYC has access to more diverse dining experiences. It is only rich people who can travel between Beijing and NYC who experience during that travel less change than they might. Effectively, the introduction of Chinese brands to the US and vice versa works like a progressive "diversity transfer" from rich people who travel a lot to poor people who don't.
Posted by: prasad | Jun 6, 2012 9:14:07 AM
As I said, all you have to do is travel to the provinces in China to find an incredible diversity of great food, music and clothing. Big cities are all very similar and pretty boring.
Posted by: Ralston McTodd | Jun 6, 2012 10:07:52 AM
Prasad, that's brilliant - diversity transfer from rich to poor - thank you!
Posted by: Zara | Jun 6, 2012 12:37:59 PM
@Prasad: Does H&M in China sell clothing made in USA? You do recall having seen Hondas and Volkswagens in the US right?
Posted by: Raza | Jun 6, 2012 3:25:42 PM
Post a comment