May 02, 2012
Unexceptionalism: A Primer
E. L. Doctorow in the New York Times:
To achieve unexceptionalism, the political ideal that would render the United States indistinguishable from the impoverished, traditionally undemocratic, brutal or catatonic countries of the world, do the following:
PHASE ONE
If you’re a justice of the Supreme Court, ignore the first sacrament of a democracy and suspend the counting of ballots in a presidential election. Appoint the candidate of your choice as president.
If you’re the newly anointed president, react to a terrorist attack by invading a nonterrorist country. Despite the loss or disablement of untold numbers of lives, manage your war so that its results will be indeterminate.
Using the state of war as justification, order secret surveillance of American citizens, data mine their phone calls and e-mail, make business, medical and public library records available to government agencies, perform illegal warrantless searches of homes and offices.
Take to torturing terrorism suspects, here or abroad, in violation of the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution, which prohibits the infliction of cruel and unusual punishment. Unilaterally abrogate the Convention Against Torture as well as the Geneva Conventions regarding the treatment of prisoners of war.
More here.
Posted by S. Abbas Raza at 11:30 AM | Permalink






















Comments
This is wonderful. So much truth in so few words. Too much for most, probably.
Posted by: reader | May 2, 2012 11:32:09 AM
Great piece. Just the facts. Oh, maybe add "then call yourself a virgin."
Posted by: Dredd | May 2, 2012 12:52:23 PM
This has some degree of truth to it, but "treat immigrants as criminals whenever possible"?? Immigrants are people who apply for american citezenship and establish themselves as residents of this country through a non discriminatory legal process. Those people are highly valued and certainly not treated like criminals. People who cross the border of our country illegally and suck money out of our economy by sending it back to thier family: they, just based on that, are in fact criminals. They are not immigrants, which is a legal status. I'm sick of people calling them that.
Posted by: Will | May 2, 2012 6:35:55 PM
To Will: Missing from this list is the differentiation of the free flow of capital and products from the "illicit" flow of labor, so that workers migrating to advantage are labelled as criminals and exploitable by employers.
Posted by: Erich | May 2, 2012 7:34:22 PM
@erich: The flow of labor wouldnt be illicit if they went through the proper procedures. They wouldnt even need citizenship, just the right permit. And they wouldnt be in the position to be exploited. Theyll put amazing amounts of effort into sneaking themselves over here, I just dont understand why they dont go through the legal process.
Im guessing it has to do with taxes...
Its not like they get paid much to begin with.
Posted by: Will | May 2, 2012 8:41:20 PM
Will,
I am a legal immigrant to the U.S. Let me assure you that I was treated pretty much as a criminal. The legal immigration process in this country can only be described as Kafkaesque. For the 7 years it took to get a green card an applicant for permanent residency (green card) is unable to leave the country unless they get a form called "advance parole". At the airport, it is necessary to show this form and then undergo what is called "secondary inspection". There is a room in JFK for just this purpose. It is full of fearful people who are castigated by guards if they so much as leave their seats. At the far end is a podium, raised at least 15 feet in the air. When your number is finally called (after about 2 hours)you approach the high podium offering your wretched "advanced parole" document to the god like official. By the time we got back to the luggage claim area, our luggage had been busted open by TSA for fear that it was abandoned and might contain a bomb. All this after a 13 hour flight from Asia. As well, before you get a green card, you are fingerprinted. At every stage of the process, the prospective immigrant is treated with suspicion - exactly like a criminal.
Posted by: reader | May 3, 2012 9:56:33 AM
Post a comment