September 17, 2011
The Better Angels of Our Nature: The Decline of Violence in History and Its Causes
Andrew Anthony in The Guardian:
Human nature is a highly contested concept, but whatever it may amount to, it doesn't seem to involve a thirst for good news. Which may be a problem for Steven Pinker, who has dedicated much of his academic life to the study of human nature, because his latest book is full of good news.
In The Better Angels of Our Nature: The Decline of Violence in History and Its Causes, the celebrated evolutionary psychologist and bestselling author argues that we – the human race – are becoming progressively less violent. To the consumer of 24-hour news, steeped in images of conflict and war, that may sound plain wrong. But Pinker supports his case with a wealth of data.
Drawing on the work of the archaeologist Lawrence Keeley, Pinker recently concluded that the chance of our ancient hunter-gatherer ancestors meeting a bloody end was somewhere between 15% and 60%. In the 20th century, which included two world wars and the mass killers Stalin and Hitler, the likelihood of a European or American dying a violent death was less than 1%.
Pinker shows that, with notable exceptions, the long-term trend for murder and violence has been going down since humans first developed agriculture 10,000 years ago. And it has dropped steeply since the Middle Ages. It may come as a surprise to fans of Inspector Morse but Oxford in the 1300s, Pinker tells us, was 110 times more murderous than it is today. With a nod to the German sociologist Norbert Elias, Pinker calls this movement away from killing the "civilising process".
More here.
Posted by S. Abbas Raza at 11:23 PM | Permalink






















Comments
In Mr. Pinker's research does he look only at the levels of violence or does he take into account the level of ignorance as well--what people 10,000 years ago knew and what they believed in or their belief systems based on the information they had ---how does that compare to the violence today with all the knowledge, technology and global awareness today which should stop us from violence--how does violence compare then? Also people ten thousand years ago or till the first half of the 20th century did not have the means to end the planet. Does he take into account the violence being done to the entire planet and its species or do the better angels not care about nature.
Posted by: maniza | Sep 18, 2011 8:21:32 AM
No one cares about nature but us - people. And we didn't start caring until we were rich enough to treat it as a consumption good rather than an industrial input.
Posted by: Philosopher's Beard | Sep 18, 2011 6:58:41 PM
I stereotype upper-class lefties rather shamelessly when it comes to this topic (I am trying to say that I know they are not ALL obsessed with the fallen state of modern man in a quasi-religious manner), but the stereotype does have some basis in reality. I suggest we discuss not only the decline of violence, but also why some people whose lives most reflect this decline are so offended by the possibility?
The topic is being discussed at http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/gnxp/2011/09/rational-optimist-or-scientific-racist/
Feel free to comment..
Posted by: omar | Sep 18, 2011 10:39:00 PM
"how does that compare to the violence today with all the knowledge, technology and global awareness today which should stop us from violence--how does violence compare then?"
Pinker's point is that human being have been doing an increasingly better job of limiting and preventing violence because we've been acquiring the skills necessary. We're imperfect as yet, but that imperfection is far better than anything previously achieved.
"Does he take into account the violence being done to the entire planet and its species or do the better angels not care about nature."
Human beings have been inflicting a heavy toll on nature for millennia. Look at all the mass extinctions visited on different continent's biospheres as soon as humans arrive (the Americas, Australia), or the long-term degradation of environments by the earliest agrarian civilizations.
Posted by: Randy McDonald | Sep 18, 2011 11:20:35 PM
Post a comment