March 29, 2011
Middle Eastern upheaval and the promise of American life
Rochelle Gurstein in The New Republic:
When the inspiring images of hundreds of thousands of Egyptian men and women demanding their freedom at enormous personal risk first appeared and everybody was talking about whether that revolution would spark similar revolutions in nearby countries, I found myself saying to friends, "What about here? Maybe the example of their courageous actions will shake the American people out of their long apathetic stupor." Inevitably I was met with laughter. Sometimes I felt a friend's laughter was conspiratorial—the exhilaration of imagining together that things could be different from what they are. Other times, I knew it was a response to what a friend found absurd, ridiculous, in my proposition. "We already had our revolution in 1776. Sure, things are bad, people are out of work, but we're not living in a police state like Egypt. I don't see you out on the street." And then there were the times when the laughter sounded nervous, a friend made uncomfortable by such talk, insisting that it couldn't happen here. I reminded these skeptical/cynical/realist friends (take your pick) that no one imagined that revolutions could happen in Tunisia or in Egypt and certainly not through the highly disciplined tactics of non-violent resistance. Or that the Soviet Union would collapse or that the Berlin Wall would be dismantled.
More here.
Posted by S. Abbas Raza at 03:25 AM | Permalink






















Comments
"Now is the winter of our discontent"
To have an upheaval in rich country you need an economic and social rights situation as in poor country; what make all this a contradiction in terms. To have this revolt the rich country (here USA) has to become a poor country in comparative global terms.
What Rochelle Gurstein see in Wisconsin are only the activists, the foam of the discontent wave.
The Egyptian activists were the foam that was riding the wave of the economic discontent of no food - no work- no hope of the masses. This is an economic condition that doesn't exist (yet) in USA.
Also Rochelle Gurstein speak again and again of Republicans as culprits; the bailout of the corporations was done mostly by Democrats and the situation described is a typical situation of this stage of global capitalism and it will not change drastic under a Republican or Democrat rule. It will change under a Communist and/or Fascist rule, but I hope that USA will not pass from an actual bad dream to a nightmare.
Posted by: Mirel | Mar 30, 2011 9:03:59 AM
Post a comment