June 11, 2010
3QD Science Prize 2010 Finalists
Hello, The editors of 3QD have made their decision. The twenty semifinalists have been winnowed down and wildcards added. Thanks to all the participants. (Details about the prize here.)
Once again, Carla Goller has provided a "trophy" logo that our finalists may choose to display on their own blogs. And if you like our site, please do add us to your blogroll and tell your friends.
So, here it is, the final list that I am sending to Richard Dawkins, who will select the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd prize winners from these: (given here in alphabetical order by blog name)
- Cosmic Variance: Free Energy and the Meaning of Life
- My Growing Passion: The Evolution of Chloroplasts
- Not Exactly Rocket Science: Gut bacteria in Japanese people borrowed digesting genes from ocean bacteria
- Observations of a Nerd: Evolution: The Curious Case of Dogs
- Scientific Blogging: MSL: Mars Action Hero
- The Loom: Skullcaps and Genomes
- The Primate Diaries: Chimpanzees Prefer Fair Play to Reaping an Unjust Reward
- The Thoughtful Animal: Does oral sex confer an evolutionary advantage? Evidence from bats
- University of Oxford Science Blog: Oxford and the Royal Society's Origins
We'll announce the three winners on June 21, 2010.
Good luck!
Abbas
P.S. The editors of 3QD will not be making any comments on our deliberations, or the process by which we made our decision, other than to simply say that we picked what we thought were the best six posts out of the semifinalists, and added up to three others that we also liked.
Posted by S. Abbas Raza at 12:17 AM | Permalink






















Comments
Sean Carroll, Margaret Morgan, Ed Young, Christie Wilcox, Ryan Anderson, Carl Zimmer, Eric Michael Johnson, Jason G. Goldman, and Pete Wilton:
Congratulations to all you Finalists! Yours are superior articles that make the rest of envious, and motivated to try again.
Abbas and the editors: Way Cool!
Posted by: Norman Costa | Jun 11, 2010 9:46:34 AM
If you are in competition mode there are 10 days left to enter this contest!
http://www.tompainesghost.com/2010/06/enter-this-contest-post-with-most.html
Posted by: Kris | Jun 11, 2010 11:31:25 AM
From what I can tell, the article Free Energy and the Meaning of Life seems to be based on some fundamental misunderstandings. The reduction of carbon dioxide to form methane is only energetically favorable in severely anoxic conditions. Otherwise, the oxidation of organic compounds into carbon dioxide is a far more efficient form of metabolic energy, and indeed is used by almost all existing forms of life, minus a handful of oddball microbes.
In all forms of metabolism, of course, the purpose is to extract energy from chemical reactions at the expense of increasing global entropy. The fact that organisms are complex systems is a red herring—this complexity is offset by the vastly greater increase in environmental entropy that results from steady metabolism. The fact that organisms "ride" on this thermodynamic stream is not a novel observation, and it has nothing to do with the particular form of metabolism used by methanogens.
Posted by: Neurosloth | Jun 11, 2010 5:38:50 PM
Congrats, everyone!
Posted by: Elatia Harris | Jun 11, 2010 11:36:07 PM
Thanks everyone! I'm incredibly flattered to have my article included in such a great list of finalists!
Posted by: Ryan Anderson | Jun 12, 2010 1:47:30 AM
Thank you so much. This is such a thrill. I'm feeling inspired!
Posted by: monocotyledon | Jun 12, 2010 1:49:51 AM
It is really exciting moment,when I watch the TV about the same situation,I was anxious,so the article gives me the memory of that,I want to go home to see my parents.I love them.
Posted by: sto credits | Jul 9, 2010 3:42:49 AM
Post a comment