April 07, 2010
Is white the new black?
Glenn Beck excels at expressing adventurous thoughts in memorable language, but he outdid himself when, one morning last summer, he offered a diagnosis of President Obama. He said, “This President, I think, has exposed himself as a guy, over and over and over again, who has a deep-seated hatred for white people, or the white culture. I don’t know what it is.” (The context was one of the summer’s most entertaining reality shows—the one starring the black Harvard professor and the white police officer who arrested him.) In September, Beck sat for an interview with Katie Couric, and she asked him a deceptively simple question, which had been posed by a Twitter user named adrianinflorida: “what did u mean white culture?” Whatever adventurous thoughts this query inspired, Beck did not seem eager to share them. “Um, I, I don’t know,” he said. Finally, after two minutes of temporizing, he arrived at a nonresponsive response that was both honest and sensible: “What is the white culture? I don’t know how to answer that that’s not a trap, you know what I mean?” Often, the most appropriate answer to that question is a joke, or a series of jokes. In 2008, a canny young white Canadian named Christian Lander started a blog called “Stuff White People Like,” which soon became a best-selling book bearing the same title; it listed a hundred and fifty of white people’s favorite things, from recycling to the Red Sox. (This magazine made the list, too, at No. 114.)more from Kelefa Sanneh at The New Yorker here.
Posted by Morgan Meis at 04:46 PM | Permalink




















Comments
Three hypotheses about race in America:
1. It's about culture: the divisions are cultural, not racial, except that racial appearance is recognised as a definitive cultural marker.
2. There's no specifically white culture, that is, culture that white people generally share in and others generally don't. However, there is Irish-American culture, Italian-American culture and so forth.
3. There's little interest in challenging the "one drop rule" that determines that anyone with any perceptible black African ancestry is black, even though it has its origins in slavery and racist notions of purity and pollution.
Curiously, in Brazil the "one drop rule" goes the other way: one is considered white in Brazil if one has any perceptible white ancestry. People travelling between the two countries sometimes find their race reassigned.
There are people such as Barack Obama and Halle Berry who are considered black in America, but were raised by white parents only and come across to white people at some level not so much as "black" but as "happens to be black". I suspect this made Obama electable in a way that Jesse Jackson wasn't. Berry says she lets people categorise her as they wish; a few years ago she appeared in a PSA ad for the MLK Foundation's "Build the Dream", which shows her being seated in a section of a restaurant in a hypothetical world where segregation never ended (apparently not available on YouTube). I believe it gets its punch from white people subconsciously reading Berry as "one of us".
Posted by: Sagredo | Apr 8, 2010 3:50:03 AM
To recap other criticisms of the Stuff White People Like blog, it's really about America's young upper-middle class, which Lander is both poking fun at and celebrating, plus a little bit of poking fun at white ignorance of other cultures for credibility for its edgy premise. Thus it would exclude non-white people from the prosperous and well-educated set.
Posted by: Sagredo | Apr 8, 2010 4:05:33 AM
Sagredo: yes, exactly, thank you for breathing some sanity in. The so-called "Stuff White People Like" is a disgusting book that appropriates the word "white" as an umbrella term to refer to any Caucasian person (clearly the daft author refers to skin tone alone, and not ancestry), when in fact what the book focuses on is not that, but only what America's youngish, white, privileged, upper-middle class, and lastly but most importantly, self-absorbed and ignorant materialists like. So actually, to be accurate and not stick another wedge between the 'whites' and all the other ethnicities/races, as the book in fact racistly does, thus perpetuating hate and polemics all around, it would have to be titled "Stuff that Privileged, Young, White, Upper-Middle Class, Self-Absorbed, Ignorant American Materialists Like."
Posted by: yawn | Apr 11, 2010 12:30:41 AM
Post a comment