March 06, 2010
Judith Butler: As a Jew, I was taught it was ethically imperative to speak up
Udi Aloni in Haaretz:
Philosopher, professor and author Judith Butler arrived in Israel this month, en route to the West Bank, where she was to give a seminar at Bir Zeit University, visit the theater in Jenin, and meet privately with friends and students. A leading light in her field, Butler chose not to visit any academic institutions in Israel itself. In the conversation below, conducted in New York several months ago, Butler talks about gender, the dehumanization of Gazans, and how Jewish values drove her to criticize the actions of the State of Israel.
In Israel, people know you well. Your name was even in the popular film Ha-Buah [The Bubble - the tragic tale of a gay relationship between an Israeli Jew and a Palestinian Muslim].
[laughs] Although I disagreed with the use of my name in that context. I mean, it was very funny to say, "don't Judith Butler me," but "to Judith Butler someone" meant to say something very negative about men and to identify with a form of feminism that was against men. And I've never been identified with that form of feminism. That?s not my mode. I'm not known for that. So it seems like it was confusing me with a radical feminist view that one would associate with Catharine MacKinnon or Andrea Dworkin, a completely different feminist modality. I'm not always calling into question who's a man and who's not, and am I a man? Maybe I'm a man. [laughs] Call me a man. I am much more open about categories of gender, and my feminism has been about women's safety from violence, increased literacy, decreased poverty and more equality. I was never against the category of men.
More here.
Posted by Abbas Raza at 11:43 PM | Permalink



















Comments
Wow: I never thought I'd say this, but I suddenly have respect for Judith Butler.
My opinion of her was soured ever since I read Martha Nussbaum's devastating critique of her ("Professor of Parady," in the New Republic, I think). I read some of Butler's stuff in grad school, including her nonsense on "performativity," which I found either derivative or just plain shallow.
However, she's a very popular academic and extremely influential among humanities types. So, if she can use her popularity and influence for an admirable political cause, then all the power to her.
Posted by: Belgian Beer | Mar 7, 2010 9:25:04 AM
A wonderful woman. Now, how about an Arab womaan being critical of Hamas, Hizbollah?
Posted by: fred lapides | Mar 7, 2010 9:35:45 AM
@ fred : I think it's much more difficult for women to come out against groups like Hamas for obvious reasons. The link I am sharing is one such example, and although it's not directed at Hamas or Hizbollah, it does discuss many of there beliefs and just why so few women have spoken against them.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ciOGS6r97oE
Posted by: michael star | Mar 7, 2010 1:01:12 PM
I used this link in a post corresponding with Israeli Apartheid Week.
http://bit.ly/9UEkBO
Posted by: John Ballard | Mar 8, 2010 8:56:02 PM
Post a comment