March 21, 2010
Gandhians with a Gun? Arundhati Roy plunges into the sea of Gondi people
Arundhati Roy in Outlook India:
There are many ways to describe Dantewada. It’s an oxymoron. It’s a border town smack in the heart of India. It’s the epicentre of a war. It’s an upside down, inside out town.
In Dantewada, the police wear plain clothes and the rebels wear uniforms. The jail superintendent is in jail. The prisoners are free (three hundred of them escaped from the old town jail two years ago). Women who have been raped are in police custody. The rapists give speeches in the bazaar.
Across the Indravati river, in the area controlled by the Maoists, is the place the police call ‘Pakistan’. There the villages are empty, but the forest is full of people. Children who ought to be in school run wild. In the lovely forest villages, the concrete school buildings have either been blown up and lie in a heap, or they are full of policemen. The deadly war that is unfolding in the jungle is a war that the Government of India is both proud and shy of. Operation Green Hunt has been proclaimed as well as denied. P. Chidambaram, India’s home minister (and CEO of the war), says it does not exist, that it’s a media creation. And yet substantial funds have been allocated to it and tens of thousands of troops are being mobilised for it. Though the theatre of war is in the jungles of Central India, it will have serious consequences for us all.
More here. [Thanks to Manan Ahmed.]
Posted by Abbas Raza at 03:53 AM | Permalink




















Comments
India and America have something in common.
America has 1,500,000 homeless children.
Homeless adults is an even greater number.
It seems that our poor scholarship and media in America only looks at foreign nations when our exceptionalism is threatened, and we need to show "how bad the rest of the world is" compared to America.
Posted by: Dredd | Mar 21, 2010 9:40:36 AM
Remarkable article, met with almost universal condemnation in the comments. Almost the only favorable reactions were from persons with Indian names, but overseas locations.
No sympathy for lawless rebels killing innocent national police. Comments to the effect 'the government has declared this movement a danger, so that's that!'
Posted by: Alice de Tocqueville | Mar 21, 2010 1:27:32 PM
I have seen strategic hamleting in Mizoram around 1977. Roy explains where the idea came from.
Posted by: gaddeswarup | Mar 22, 2010 6:06:09 PM
Admiration for Roy's fiery articles is definitely on the wane. I guess people realize what they're signing up for, when they support some of Roy's causes: Moonwalking with the Comrades
Posted by: Fortinbras | Mar 23, 2010 12:10:18 AM
I do not know about Arundhati Roy's other artcles since this is the only one that I read. Much similar material is in Rahul Banerjee's book "Recovering the Lost Tongue: The Saga of Environmental Struggles in Cental India". From this and what I have seen in Meghalaya, Mizoram many of the facts mentioned by Roy ring true to me. I think that the tribals have had many problems and perhaps taking Naxalite help since they could not get much help elsewhere.
Posted by: gaddeswarup | Mar 24, 2010 1:58:52 AM
Some more "leftist" critiques of Arundhati's article:
A Believer's Obeisance by Soumitra Ghosh
Response to Arundhati Roy by Jarius Banaji
Posted by: Fortinbras | Mar 24, 2010 11:23:35 PM
Aditya Nigam addresses many of the problems mentioned in Roy's artcle in "Rumours of Maoism" though he does not explicitly mention Arundhati Roy:
http://kafila.org/2010/03/25/rumours-of-maoism-aditya-nigam-seminar/#more-3989
A sample quote "...it would appear that it is rather the frenzied drive towards development that is breeding Maoist politics."
Posted by: gaddeswarup | Mar 25, 2010 5:47:01 PM
Post a comment