September 27, 2007
One Does Not Escape Jewishness
Ultimately, Hannah Arendt’s achievements and biases, her creativity and inner conflicts must be seen as part of the quite extraordinary history of post-emancipation German-Jewish intellectuals as they confronted German culture and its later breakdown, the experience of totalitarianism, and Jewish attempts at reconstitution. Her involvement with the Jewish world was always intense and complex, but so too was her simultaneous engagement in other cultural and political spheres. Precisely because she acutely and distinctively embodied the tensions and contradictions of these manifold worlds, she was able – sometimes more, sometimes less successfully – to grasp critically their interconnections and plumb both the despair and the possibilities of her fractured time.
more from the TLS here.
Posted by Morgan Meis at 10:15 AM | Permalink






Comments
"What had been the pride of the Jewish homeland, that it had not been based upon exploitation, turned into a curse when the final test came: the flight of the Arabs would not have been possible and not have been welcomed by the Jews if they had lived in a common economy."--but the reality was that (1) there was no unified state for Arabs and Jews but rather two areas, and that the Arab nations attacked Israel. Note too that this quote says the arabs fled; others calim they were pushed out...many claims about this. Oh, yes: and the 750 thousand Jewzs living in Arab lands?
The Wound and the Bow--many Jews torn between two worlds and somehow do major work because of this tension.
Posted by: fred lapides | Sep 27, 2007 1:49:32 PM
I've listened to several good podcasts on Arendt recently, two at Robert Harrison's "Entitled Opinions" (http://www.stanford.edu/dept/fren-ital/opinions/) and one on Christopher Lydon's Radio Open Source (http://www.radioopensource.org/hannah-arendt-and-the-banality-of-evil/).
Enjoy!
Posted by: Bryon | Sep 27, 2007 1:54:40 PM
I think Arendt means that there would have been a unified state rather than two areas if there had been a common economy, that is if the Zionists had not insisted on "Jewish labour".
Posted by: Sagredo | Sep 27, 2007 11:01:24 PM
Post a comment