June 26, 2007
Clever experiment shows altruism in great apes
From Nature:
Humans are often thought of as the only truly altruistic species. We help others out — by giving blood, donating to the poor, or committing to recycling — for no immediate payoff, and often at a cost to ourselves. But evidence is gathering that we might not be alone. Felix Warneken and colleagues at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, have shown that chimpanzees will do favours for unrelated chimps - even when they do not get rewarded for it. Previous studies have refuted the idea that chimps are so giving. In 2005, anthropologist Joan Silk of the University of California, Los Angeles, found that when she presented chimps with the choice of getting food just for themselves, or for their entire group, they showed no preference for feeding their pals as well.
But other work has shown that chimps can have a non-selfish streak. In a study published in Science last year, a Leipzig team reported that chimps would help their human keepers retrieve a pen that they had dropped — an action with no direct benefit for the chimp. That study involved chimps helping out human carers whom they were familiar with — and who had on other occasions provided the chimps with food. To get rid of these complications, the Leipzig team replicated the pen-dropping experiment with unfamiliar humans. As they now report in PLoS Biology, the chimps still chose to help out.
More here.
Posted by Azra Raza at 07:00 AM | Permalink























Comments
In a related study, humans refused to pick up a leaf for chimps...
Posted by: beajerry | Jun 26, 2007 10:22:12 AM
Chimps are probably smart enough to have learned that when you help out humans, they tend to treat you better and give you more food. Dogs do things for their owners all of the time. Besides, picking up a pen for somebody is pretty low cost (negligible, really); let's see them actually make a meaningful effort to help somebody out. It's also possible that "altruistic" behavior in chimps is learned from their human captors. To conclude that chimps have significant altruistic tendencies based upon these studies would be a mistake.
Posted by: wyatt | Jun 26, 2007 12:02:33 PM
I'd still like to see an example of true altruism in humans before we move onto other species.
Paraphrasing Wyatt: To conclude that humans have significant altruistic tendencies based upon past experience would be a mistake.
People recycle, give blood, donate money to charity, because ultimately it makes >them< feel better about themselves, about their place in society and provides them higher ground to stand on overlooking those that don't exhibit their same learned 'altruistic' tendencies.
Posted by: N Miller | Jun 26, 2007 12:38:26 PM
Don't want your @#$% pen!
Posted by: Richard Sweeton | Jun 27, 2007 9:16:20 AM
"People recycle, give blood, donate money to charity, because ultimately it makes >them< feel better about themselves,.." Does the side benefit of feeling good about oneself negate altruism?
Has any chimp handed someone back a banana that was dropped into his enclosure? That would be altruism!
Posted by: aguy109 | Jun 27, 2007 12:22:23 PM
Post a comment